By submitting this examination for grading I affirm that I have not discussed this examinationwith any other person, nor accessed or employed any information not included in the materialspresented below.Required:Write your answers in standard English.Include any computations you make in completing your answers.Be specific.1) Decompose Tesla’s ROE for the annual periods 2012-2014. Note any trends you observe.2) Tesla notes that Q1 automotive revenue includes $51 million from the sale of ZEV credits.*Assuming that 2012-2014 annual revenues are comprised of the same percentage of ZEVrevenues as was the case in Q1 of 2015, re-compute Tesla’s income after removing the effect ofthe ZEV sales and decompose ROE using the revised data.3) Compare your new calculations to your ROE decomposition from question 1.4) Comment on the quality of Tesla’s earnings.5) Given that Tesla has consistently generated losses, how has the company managed to survive?Read Tesla’s Stockholder Letter for the first quarter of 2015. Tesla repeatedly refers to “nonGAAP”results.6) What are the specific departures Tesla makes from GAAP in computing these numbers?7) Why do you think the company keeps referring to “non-GAAP” measures?*Here’s how ZEV (zero emission vehicle) credits work: Every major auto manufacturer in theU.S. is required to sell a given percentage of zero-emission vehicles (by 2025 it will reach 15%).Failure to meet this standard results in a fine. Manufacturers receive zero emission vehicle“credits” for each ZEV sold. ZEV sales were, however, only 1% of automotive sales in 2014.This means many manufacturers fall below the threshold. They can, however, buy “credits” fromother companies in order to keep from paying the fines. Since Tesla only sells ZEVs it has “extra”credits that it can sell.
Recent Comments